Pages That Disagree

When two pages state opposite facts, AI Knowledge shows both passages so you can say which is right.

Applies To

liveknowledge

Two pages that say different things are worse than one page that says nothing: whoever reads the wrong one acts on it. liveknowledge looks for such pairs as pages change, and lists each under Pages That Disagree in the AI Knowledge tab of the footer.

Two pages that disagree: the question both answer, each passage with its page's trust, and the ways to settle it.

How a Disagreement Is Found

  • When a page is verified, or its writing is saved, liveknowledge finds passages on other pages that match its passages and asks the model whether any pair states opposite facts. A page is checked at most once every 10 minutes.
  • It runs on built-in AI, included, or on the team's own key if it added one. On a server with no built-in AI and no key, a line says so, and an Editor sees Open AI Settings. See AI Settings.
  • A Knowledgebase is checked at most 20 times a day on built-in AI and 50 on its own key, and each check compares at most 5 passages.

Each pair shows the question both passages answer, the two passages side by side (stacked on a phone), and each page's trust: Verified and when, Review Due, or Never Verified.

Settle It

Read both passages. Their pages' trust is a clue: a passage on a page verified last week is more likely right than one on a page whose review is due.

Press <Page> Is Right, Fix the Other on the side that is right (for example, Deploying Is Right, Fix the Other). The other page opens, for you to correct.

Save the correction. Once either passage changes, the pair closes by itself.

Not sure which is right? Press Ask Both Owners. Each owner of the two pages gets one email, "Two Pages Disagree", with the question, both pages linked, each passage (up to 280 characters) and a link to this view. Once they are asked, "Owners asked" and the date stand in the button's place. A pair's owners are asked once.

Not a real disagreement (two pages about different things that only sound alike)? Press Not a Conflict. That pair never comes back.

Ask Both Owners, in Detail

The email is one of the Knowledgebase Reviews emails, so it follows the same rules as Remind the Owners: an owner who turned these emails off, or who can no longer open the Knowledgebase, is not sent one, and a Knowledgebase sends at most 50 review emails a day. The toast says what happened, for example "Sent to 2 owners.", or "Neither page has an owner to ask. Set one in Page Health." The button is shown only where this server sends email.

Good to Know

  • With nothing to settle, the section reads No Disagreements Yet.
  • Ask uses this too: a passage on an out-of-date page that disagrees with a newer verified one is shown under Found but Not Used, not in the answer. See Ask.
  • Agents are told when a passage's page is in a disagreement, by the field conflicts_with in every search result.

Who Can Do What

ActionEditorParticipantViewer
See pages that disagreeYesYesYes
Fix the other, or mark it Not a ConflictYesNoNo
Ask both ownersYesNoNo

Asking the owners needs a signed-in Editor.

Was this article helpful?

Still need help?

Try Troubleshooting, or tell us what you were trying to do.

Contact us